Managed Payroll · Compared
One quotes every company through a branch representative. One publishes its pricing online. Honest referee breakdown before you pick a login.
See your exact monthly & annual price - no call required
Contender One
Paychex has built its brand around a branch and local-representative model: a large network of regional offices and assigned reps rather than a purely centralized structure. Its published product line spans tiers from basic self-service processing up through bundled HR add-ons, marketed heavily to small and mid-size employers.
Paychex is quote-gated: no published price list, a census-based sales quote instead. It remains software your team operates every cycle: entering hours, reviewing runs, approving pay. Common complaints in public reviews center on add-on fees stacking onto the base price once a company is quoted and onboarded.
Contender Two
Gusto built its brand on transparent, published tiers designed for small and growing businesses. You can view current plan tiers and per-employee pricing directly on Gusto's pricing page before ever talking to a sales rep, a real point of differentiation against a quote-gated competitor like Paychex.
Gusto remains software: your team enters hours, reviews the run, and approves payroll every cycle. Its support model is self-service and ticket-based rather than a local-representative network, which is the direct tradeoff against Paychex's branch structure.
Side by Side
| Factor | Paychex | Gusto |
|---|---|---|
| Payroll model | Self-service software, multiple tiers | Self-service software, published tiers |
| Pricing visibility | Quote-gated, census and sales call required | Published tiers, linked on Gusto's pricing page |
| Who runs payroll | You: enter hours, review, approve each cycle | You: enter hours, review, approve each cycle |
| Tax filing responsibility | Platform files on your behalf per your tier | Platform files on your behalf per your plan |
| Ideal company size | Small and mid-size employers, tiered add-ons | Small and growing businesses |
| Support model | Branch network with assigned local representatives | Self-service help center plus support tickets |
Gusto tiers per its published pricing page. Paychex requires a sales quote for exact pricing on your company.
How to Actually Decide
Lean Paychex. Its published model is built around branch offices and assigned representatives. If you want a person in your region rather than a support ticket, that is the model Paychex sells.
Lean Gusto. Its tiers are published, so you can budget before talking to anyone. That transparency is Gusto's core differentiator against a quote-gated competitor like Paychex.
Pause before picking either. Both are tools your team operates every cycle: data entry, review, approval. If the goal is to remove that work entirely, you are comparing the wrong category.
Comparing other platforms too? See Gusto vs ADP or Rippling vs Gusto.
The Referee's Close
If you want software, Paychex and Gusto sit at different ends of the transparency and support spectrum, but both leave the actual work of running payroll on your desk. You still enter hours, review every run, and approve every cycle.
If instead you want payroll run for you, inside your existing system, at a flat rate you can see before you talk to anyone, that is BEG managed payroll: $25-$45 PEPM, all-inclusive, every filing and every W-2 handled. No software login for your team, no quote gate, no subscription tier to outgrow.
See your exact monthly & annual price - no call required
Questions
Gusto publishes its pricing tiers directly on its own pricing page. Paychex does not: it is quote-gated, requiring a census and a sales call to learn your actual cost. Compare Gusto's published number against a real Paychex quote before deciding.
Paychex's published model is built around a branch network with assigned local representatives, rather than a purely centralized support structure. Gusto's support model is self-service and ticket-based instead.
Gusto markets primarily to small and growing companies, with published tiers that add features like time tracking as you move up. Paychex spans a wider range including larger and more complex employers through its higher tiers and add-ons.
No. Both Paychex and Gusto are software you or your team operate directly. You enter hours, review each run, and approve it every cycle. Neither takes payroll off your desk.
BEG is not a party to either platform. If you want payroll run for you instead of software you log into, BEG managed payroll is the alternative: a flat $25-$45 PEPM, all-inclusive, inside your existing system, with an instant on-screen estimate instead of a sales quote or a subscription tier.
Ready?
Answer a few questions, get your exact number in about 90 seconds. No call required, no commitment.
See your exact monthly & annual price - no call required
